Dewey's Pizza guide to crust
Pizza styles explained, from thin crust to Detroit
Ordering pizza gets easier once you know what the names actually mean. Dough, pan, and cut change the whole meal.
See our menuStart here
Thin crust and what it changes
Thin crust is the everyday American style, and it is the one most pizza restaurants build their menu around. A thin pie bakes quickly, which means the toppings cook on top of a crisp base rather than steaming into the dough. It also eats cleanly by hand, which is why it works for carryout and for a table where people are standing.
The tradeoff is capacity: a thin crust holds two or three toppings well and gets soggy under a heavy load. That is why Dewey's Pizza keeps toppings balanced and bakes each pie to order, so the center stays crisp instead of soft.
A thin base bakes fast and eats cleanly by hand. Best with two or three toppings.
Bake
Short, hot bake. Toppings stay on top of the crust instead of sinking in.
Handle
Sturdy enough to pick up, light enough to share. Made for carryout, group orders, and weeknights.
Limit
Heavy loads turn the middle soft. When you want five toppings, split them across two pies.
Midwest table
Tavern-style and the square cut
Tavern-style pizza is a thin-crust Midwest tradition, usually cut into squares rather than wedges. The square cut comes from the way the pie was historically served in bars, where a grid of small pieces is easier to share than a long slice.
The crust is thin and crisp, sometimes described as cracker-like, and the pieces near the corner have more edge than the middle. If you like a high ratio of crust to topping, this is the style to look for. It is also the cut you will see at Dewey's Pizza, at 1312 Vine St in Cincinnati.
Local roots
St. Louis-style and regional identity
St. Louis-style pizza takes thin crust further, with a cracker-like base and a local cheese tradition that gives it a distinct flavor. It is cut into squares, like tavern-style, and it is tied to St. Louis dining rather than national menus.
The lesson travels: thin crust is not one thing. A local cheese, a drier sauce, or a longer bake two states away can make the same thin idea taste different.
Compare crust options
Deep-dish and stuffed pizza
Chicago deep-dish is the opposite approach: a tall, buttery crust with cheese and toppings layered inside and sauce often on top. It bakes much longer than a thin pie, and a single slice is closer to a meal than a snack.
Stuffed pizza goes further still, adding another layer of dough over the fillings. Both styles are built for a sit-down meal with a fork, which is why they rarely travel as well as a thin crust.
Detroit-style and the mainstream shift
Detroit-style pizza is baked in a rectangular tray, with cheese pushed all the way to the edges so the corners caramelize into crispy, cheesy borders. The interior is thick but airy, which separates it from a dense pan pizza.
It started as a regional style and has moved into the mainstream, appearing on menus far outside Michigan. The draw is texture: a crisp, cheesy edge that no thin crust can reproduce.
A quick comparison
Five pies, five different rules
Each one is a real category with its own pan, bake, and cut. Not a marketing label for the same pie.
Thin crust
Crisp base, fast bake, best for two or three toppings and for sharing.
Tavern-style
Thin and square-cut, more edge per piece. Built for the table.
St. Louis-style
Cracker-like base with a local cheese tradition, also square-cut.
Deep-dish
Tall buttery crust, layered fillings, fork required. Plan for time.
Detroit-style
Rectangular tray, cheese to the edges, crispy caramelized corners.
Pick by occasion
How to pick a style for your meal
Match the style to the evening you have in mind. The pan decides the pace, the cut decides how people share, and the thickness decides whether you need a fork.
Carryout or a quick dinner?
Order a thin or tavern-style pie. It bakes fast, travels well, and feeds a table sharing several pizzas without slowing the night down.
Sit-down meal where pizza is the main event?
Deep-dish and Detroit-style suit that pace. Expect a longer bake, thicker slices, and people happy to use a fork.
Want to taste a place, not just a pie?
Seek out St. Louis-style where it is made. The cracker base and local cheese carry that city with them.
Feeding a group with mixed tastes?
A thin crust is the safest base because it works with almost any topping. Order two lighter pies instead of one loaded pie.
Our crust
Where Dewey's fits
Our pies are made to order on a thin crust, closer to tavern-style than to deep-dish or Detroit-style. That choice keeps the focus on the toppings and makes the pizza practical for carryout, group orders, and a normal weeknight.
Why thin
Thin means the menu can carry seasonal specials without reworking the dough. If you want a tray-baked or deep-dish pie, you are looking for a different tradition, and now you know which one to ask for.
Next step
Deweys Pizza serves squares built for sharing. Browse the menu, check hours at 1312 Vine St, or plan a group order.
Open Mon–Sun 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM. Call +1 513-696-9520.